CASE CENTRE · PERSONAL INJURY · INSURER VOIDED POLICY · NO PROPER NOTICE · INSURER STILL LIABLE

Merino v. ING Insurance Company of Canada

2019 ONCA 326 Court of Appeal for Ontario April 25, 2019
⚠ Informational Purposes Only — Not Legal Advice

This page is a summary and commentary on a publicly available court decision, written for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship with Azimi Law, regardless of how specific or applicable it may seem to your situation.

This summary may be incomplete, simplified, or not reflect the most current state of the law — the decision may be appealed, distinguished, or overtaken by later rulings. Independently verify this case against the official decision before relying on it. Nothing here guarantees the outcome of any other matter, including yours.

Do not rely on this page to make decisions about your own situation. Consult a licensed lawyer, or contact Azimi Law to discuss your situation directly.

In short: The Court of Appeal for Ontario held that a car insurer cannot wipe out a policy retroactively because of an inaccurate application. It must use the statutory termination process. This insurer did not, so the policy was still in force when a pedestrian was catastrophically injured, and the insurer owed her the judgment against its own insureds up to the full policy limit.

The Facts

In May 2002 a couple applied through a broker for coverage on their Jeep. Only the husband signed, and the application left out the wife's poor driving record. The insurer's own underwriting review found the real history, and on July 2, 2002 it sent a registered letter saying the policy was void from the day it started. No premium had been paid and the letter did not give 15 days' notice. Believing the vehicle was uninsured, the couple stopped driving it until September 12, 2002, when the husband hit a university student crossing a road. She was catastrophically injured. In 2011 she won a $2,000,000 judgment against the owners, who could not pay, and she recovered only a small net amount (about $19,000) from her mother's insurer under uninsured motorist coverage. In 2012 she sued the original insurer directly under section 258(1) of the Insurance Act. The motion judge agreed the policy had been validly rescinded and dismissed her claim.

What the Court Decided

The Court allowed the appeal in reasons written by Justice Feldman, with two other judges agreeing. It started from section 258, which lets a person who has a judgment against an insured driver collect the insurance money directly from the insurer, but only if the policy was still alive on the accident date. A policy properly ended before then leaves nothing to collect. The real question was whether this insurer had properly ended it. The Court held that an Ontario auto insurer has no option to rescind at common law and treat the contract as though it never existed; it is bound by the statutory scheme (para. 52). A false statement in an application has statutory consequences between insurer and insured, but those do not cancel the contract, and allowing rescission would undercut the protection the legislature gave innocent third parties. The July 2002 letter also failed the regulation's termination rule, which calls for at least 15 days' notice by registered mail or five days if hand-delivered, so the policy remained in force. The insurer could still try to cut its exposure to the $200,000 statutory minimum by proving a knowing misrepresentation by the applicant, but it did not prove that. The husband denied signing as his wife's agent and nothing contradicted him. The insurer therefore owed the full $1,000,000 limit. The Court also rejected waiver and abuse-of-process arguments based on the pedestrian's earlier claim against her own insurer, because the insurer had told her the driver was uninsured, and she undertook to account for any double recovery.

This is the leading Ontario authority for the point that an auto insurer cannot simply declare a policy dead after the fact. When a driver is sued and the insurer says there was no coverage, the first question is whether the insurer ended the policy in the way the statute requires. The decision protects injured people with a judgment against a driver who believed they were uninsured, and it signals to insurers that skipped notice steps are costly. The Supreme Court of Canada later declined to hear an appeal.

“an automobile insurer in Ontario does not have the option of unilaterally rescinding a contract of insurance at common law ab initio”
— Merino v. ING Insurance Company of Canada, 2019 ONCA 326, para. 52

Does This Affect You?

  • ✓You were hurt by a driver whose insurer later said the policy was cancelled or void because of something on the application.
  • ✓You are a driver or owner told your policy was void from the start and that you were therefore uninsured.
  • ✓You hold a judgment against an at-fault driver and are trying to find out whether any insurer is on the hook.

Key Takeaways

  1. An Ontario auto insurer cannot rescind a policy at common law; it has to follow the statutory termination rules and give proper notice.
  2. If the policy was still in force on the accident date, an injured person with a judgment can usually sue the insurer directly under section 258.
  3. An insurer can still limit its exposure to the $200,000 minimum if it proves the applicant knowingly misrepresented facts, but it carries the burden of proving that.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this mean an insurer can never end a policy over a misrepresentation?
No. The decision says the insurer must act within the statute: with the required notice and within the limits the Act places on termination. What it cannot do is declare the policy void from the beginning at common law.
Does the decision say the driver who made the misstatement is covered for everything?
Not exactly. It decides that the policy remained in force for purposes of the injured person's direct claim. The insured's own rights against the insurer can be affected by a knowing misrepresentation, and the insurer may be able to cap its exposure to third parties at $200,000 if it proves one.

For related guidance, see our Accident Benefits Lawyer Toronto and Car Accident Lawyer Toronto.