CASE CENTRE · PERSONAL INJURY · MISREPRESENTATION · FALSE DRIVER · INSURER DENIED A DEFENCE

Wong v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada

2024 ONCA 874 Court of Appeal for Ontario December 2, 2024
⚠ Informational Purposes Only — Not Legal Advice

This page is a summary and commentary on a publicly available court decision, written for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship with Azimi Law, regardless of how specific or applicable it may seem to your situation.

This summary may be incomplete, simplified, or not reflect the most current state of the law — the decision may be appealed, distinguished, or overtaken by later rulings. Independently verify this case against the official decision before relying on it. Nothing here guarantees the outcome of any other matter, including yours.

Do not rely on this page to make decisions about your own situation. Consult a licensed lawyer, or contact Azimi Law to discuss your situation directly.

In short: The Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld a finding of civil fraud against a driver who persuaded her mother to say she had been driving. The insurer discovered the lie and refused to defend either woman. The court rejected the argument that the insurer had lost nothing, because its capacity to defend the lawsuit was harmed even if the dollar cost could not yet be counted.

The Facts

In March 2019 Victoria Wong was driving her mother's car when it was involved in a collision. Believing her driver's licence had expired, she phoned her mother to ask that she attend the scene and claim to have been the driver. The false account was repeated at the collision reporting centre, in the claim to Aviva, to the police, and even after the other driver started a lawsuit. Aviva found out during discovery examinations in that lawsuit and declined to defend or indemnify either woman. Ms. Wong applied for a declaration that Aviva still owed her a defence. The application judge dismissed it, finding that she had breached the policy, made material misrepresentations and committed civil fraud. On appeal she challenged only the civil fraud finding, saying it was unnecessary and that Aviva suffered no loss it could measure.

What the Court Decided

The panel (MacPherson, Roberts and Wilson JJ.A.) heard only from the appellant, said it need not hear from the insurer and dismissed the appeal, giving reasons on December 2, 2024. It set out the four elements of civil fraud from Hryniak v. Mauldin (para. 6): a false statement, knowledge of its falsity, action in reliance and resulting loss. The disagreement was about loss. The application judge had found that the proceedings so far were of little value except to the other driver, who could use them to attack Ms. Wong's credibility, which left the insurer at a disadvantage, and the Court of Appeal saw no error and deferred to that finding (paras. 7-8). It accepted that the cost of the defence could not yet be quantified because damages in the main action were not fixed, but held that the insurer had nonetheless suffered a concrete loss in how it could conduct the defence (para. 9). Costs of $4,000 were ordered against Ms. Wong (para. 10).

Lying to an insurer about who was driving is one of the quickest ways to lose coverage, and it can leave a driver facing a lawsuit alone, with no defence and no insurer to pay a judgment. This short decision confirms that the loss element of civil fraud does not require a calculated sum: damage to the insurer's ability to defend the case is enough. It does not say anything about relief from forfeiture, because that was not appealed. Anyone who has already given an inaccurate account to an insurer should get advice before the next step, not after.

“This is a real loss, not a speculative one”
— Wong v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2024 ONCA 874, para. 9

Does This Affect You?

  • ✓You gave your insurer or the police a version of events that was not accurate, such as who was driving.
  • ✓Your insurer has denied you a defence or coverage after discovering a misstatement.
  • ✓You are an injured person suing a driver whose insurer has pulled out, leaving the driver effectively uninsured.

Key Takeaways

  1. A false statement to an auto insurer about who was driving can support a civil fraud finding and a denial of defence and indemnity.
  2. The insurer's loss does not have to be a fixed dollar figure; harm to its ability to defend the claim counts.
  3. A driver who loses coverage this way may face the lawsuit, and any judgment, without an insurer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Court of Appeal decide whether she should get relief from forfeiture?
No. She appealed only the finding of civil fraud, so the appeal reasons deal only with that. The coverage denial itself was not reopened in this ruling.
Does an injured plaintiff still have anywhere to turn if the driver's insurer withdraws?
Possibly. The options depend on the facts: your own uninsured or family protection coverage, or in some situations a claim against the Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund after a judgment. Which applies has to be looked at case by case.