Pepa v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration)
This page is a summary and commentary on a publicly available court decision, written for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship with Azimi Law, regardless of how specific or applicable it may seem to your situation.
This summary may be incomplete, simplified, or not reflect the most current state of the law — the decision may be appealed, distinguished, or overtaken by later rulings. Independently verify this case against the official decision before relying on it. Nothing here guarantees the outcome of any other matter, including yours.
Do not rely on this page to make decisions about your own situation. Consult a licensed lawyer, or contact Azimi Law to discuss your situation directly.
The Facts
Dorinela Pepa left Albania in 2018, at the age of 20, holding a permanent resident visa as an accompanying dependent child of her father. Shortly before travelling she had married. When she told the border officer, she no longer fit the dependent-child category and could not be landed as a permanent resident, so she was allowed into Canada only so that her situation could be examined further. Her visa lapsed in mid-September 2018, before the examination was finished, and the admissibility hearing took place about nine days later. It ended in a removal order and a five-year bar on returning. Ms. Pepa then tried to appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division under section 63(2) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, which allows a foreign national who holds a permanent resident visa to appeal such an order. In August 2019 the Division declined to hear the appeal, reasoning that her visa had expired before the order was made, so she no longer held one. The Federal Court and the Federal Court of Appeal both found that conclusion reasonable. The Supreme Court heard her appeal in December 2024.
What the Court Decided
Justice Martin, writing for a majority of six, allowed the appeal in June 2025. The Court applied the reasonableness framework from Vavilov and found the Division's reasons inadequate. The Division had relied on earlier decisions that were made under an older version of the provision, involved a different situation such as a revoked rather than an expired visa, or did not bind it, and it never carried out its own reading of the section's words, context and purpose. The present-tense wording of the provision did not settle the timing question. Reading the section in light of its purpose and its effect on people, the majority concluded that the only reasonable interpretation is that a foreign national may appeal if the visa was valid when they arrived in Canada. A reading that lets the right vanish because a hearing is scheduled after the visa runs out, before any removal order exists, would leave the appeal right close to empty and make it depend on scheduling delays the person cannot control. The majority also stressed what was at stake for Ms. Pepa: separation from her family in Canada and a five-year exclusion. The decisions below were set aside and the appeal was sent back to the Division to be heard on its merits. Justice Rowe agreed that the Division's decision was unreasonable but disagreed on the remedy, preferring to let the Division reconsider its jurisdiction. Justices Côté and O'Bonsawin would have dismissed the appeal, finding the Division's approach reasonable and warning of knock-on effects for other parts of the statute.
Before this ruling, a person whose visa lapsed while the case was pending could be told the appeal door was closed. The decision protects the appeal right of visa holders who arrived while their visa was valid. It is also a leading reminder that a tribunal cannot simply rest on a line of older cases without checking that they fit the current wording and facts. It does not decide how any appeal will turn out, and it addresses section 63(2) only.
Does This Affect You?
- ✓You arrived in Canada on a valid permanent resident visa, were referred to an admissibility hearing, and the visa expired before the hearing or before a removal order was made.
- ✓You were told the Immigration Appeal Division cannot hear your appeal because your visa is no longer in force.
- ✓Your appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction on that basis and you want to understand whether this ruling changes your position.
Key Takeaways
- For the section 63(2) appeal right, the question is whether the permanent resident visa was valid when you arrived in Canada, not whether it was still in force on the day of the hearing or the removal order.
- A tribunal that leans on earlier decisions must explain why they still apply to the current wording and the facts in front of it; repeating a line of cases without its own analysis can make a decision unreasonable.
- Winning the jurisdiction point reopens the appeal. It does not decide whether the removal order will be set aside.